Mar 27 2009
When Do You Lay It All Out?
Do you have a secret?
Is it a tiny little secret, or a big whopper that haunts you in the dark? Are you keeping it from someone you barely know, or hiding it from someone you deeply love? Are you looking for the perfect time and place to tell someone your secret, or are you perfectly content to let it stay clandestine?
As you can tell, I have a secret. It’s from my son. I haven’t told him yet because….well…he’s not quite 3. He wouldn’t get it. But I will. Yeah….I’m pretty sure I will.
No really…I will! I promise!
But how? How do you tell a little kid that they’re adopted? What will that mean to him?
I have some great commenters. On my post yesterday, Ken @ Dad to Two mentioned he found out about his secret when he was 39. Kristy mentioned she found out when she was 7. Shelly revealed she’s adopted, but didn’t mention at what age she found out. Carl said that his uncle didn’t find out till he was 40. I could go on, but the theme here is that there is no magic formula to follow. When is the best time? When is the worst?
This dilemma is something I’ve considered since the day I started thinking about adopting. I know it’s something I’ve come to terms with, which I hope would be obvious. I don’t care that my son is not biologically mine. I love him with all my heart and soul. But that doesn’t necessarily mean he will have an easy time dealing with it. I sincerely hope our good bond and healthy parent/child relationship will mean something, but I can’t say we won’t have our challenges.
I know…I just KNOW…that day will come when we argue about something. I’ll send him to his room or ground him, and he’s going to fire back with “you’re not my real mom,” or “I want to go live with my real mom.”
Well, you’re stuck me, Kiddo. You’re wasting your breath. After all, I’M your real mom, for better or for worse.
Anyway, I’m slipping off subject. What I want to know is when I should tell him.
I did a lot of research on the subject before and during our license process. The experts generally agree that the child should be told early and often. It should be treated like it’s no big deal, and just a part of who they are. One suggestion was to start telling to them as infants like a bedtime story. Sure, they may not understand what you’re actually saying, but to think of it as a rehearsal. That way, when they were finally old enough to understand, you are so used to telling the story that it’s not a big deal.
At first, I liked this option. I thought for sure I could do that. But the more I thought about it, the more I decided against it. First of all, you’re then talking about adoption with your kids ALL THE TIME. It’s like you spend time every day pointing out the differences in your family. Then your kids are always thinking about it, then comparing themselves to the kids around them, and constantly dwelling on something that makes them different. I don’t want him to do that. I want him to enjoy being a kid. I want him to know, but not obsess.
Then there’s the “son we need to talk” approach. Wait until they’re of an age they can comprehend these kinds of things (like Kristy’s 7 years) and sit them down. I’m not sure I like that approach, either. How do you determine that magic age?
My approach thus far has been to document. I have scrapbooks about the early days, with bubbles of dialog filled in that say things like “Our first visit” and “The day you came home.” The picture that follows is clearly NOT that of a newborn. His previous foster mom was good enough to give us a few pics of some of the firsts we missed, and those are in his scrapbook, too. My labels says “Even though we weren’t with you yet…”
Kiddo loves to look at these books. Although it’s somewhat accidental, I suppose this will be the tool we use to help start that understanding with him. We’ll see how well that works out.








